(back to index )


Add Another Statute to the List of (Potentially) Un-Releasable Laws: USERRA

The California Court of Appeal recently decided in Perez v. Uline, Inc. that a general release was ineffective against a later claim for wrongful termination in violation of public policy based on the Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act ("USERRA"). However, this decision appears to be inconsistent with a 2006 Georgia federal court decision which suggested that USERRA claims are waivable, provided that the release is "clear, convincing, specific, unequivocal, and not under duress."

USERRA contains language which states:

"This chapter supersedes any State law ... contract, agreement, ... or other matter that reduces, limits, or eliminates in any manner any right or benefit provided by this chapter. ..."

In Perez, on the day the plaintiff, a captain in the United States Marine Corps Reserves, returned to work, he was told that his employer no longer needed his services. He signed a "severance agreement and release" in return for six weeks' salary. Subsequently Perez sued his former employer alleging, among other things, wrongful termination in violation of public policy — including termination of members of the armed services in violation of USERRA. Applying USERRA's language that it supercedes any contract or agreement limiting rights under that statute, the Court of Appeal held that releases of USERRA claims are invalid.

USERRA claims are likely to become more prevalent as more soldiers return to work from active duty, and employers need to be aware of their obligations under this law. How other courts decide the question of whether USERRA claims are waivable remains to be seen, but Perez should serve as a caution to any employer seeking to have such claims released. We strongly encourage you to consult with your Schiff Hardin Labor and Employment attorney before entering into any severance agreement or other release with an employee who might have rights under USERRA.


Schiff Hardin Labor and Employment Group
Thurston C. Bailey
312.258.5561
Charlene Q. Kalebic
847.295.4335
Patricia Costello Slovak
312.258.5665
Eric L. Barnum
404.437.7013
Bita A. Karabian
415.901.8765
Drahcir M. Smith
404.437.7038
Howard R. Barron
312.258.5558
Paula M. Ketcham
312.258.5539
Sarah R. Speakman
415.901.8620
Wendi J. Berkowitz
415.901.8752
Matthew D. Lahey
312.258.5674
Kathleen A. Stimeling
415.901.8700
Max G. Brittain Jr.
312.258.5544
Neil Lloyd
312.258.5628
William J. Carroll
415.901.8754
Catherine M. Masters
312.258.5565
Richard L. Verkler
847.295.4300
Nicole Finitzo
847.295.4308
Ralph A. Morris
312.258.5553
Bruce A. Wagman
415.901.8762
Laura B. Friedel
312.258.5673
Lee Ann Rabe
312.258.5527 
Nora Kersten Walsh
312.258.5530
Julie J. Furer
312.258.5689
Dana D. Rice
312.258.5622  
Ronald Wilder
312.258.5610
Stephen M. Hankins
415.901.8756
Marc L. Silverman
212.745.0872 
Tamera M. Woodard
404.437.7016

Henry W. Sledz Jr.
312.258.5525
Brenna Woodley
312.258.5738


Schiff Hardin LLP

One Atlantic Center,
Suite 2300
1201 West Peachtree Street
Atlanta, GA 30309
  225 Franklin Street,
Suite 2600 
Boston, MA 02110 
  6600 Sears Tower
233 S Wacker Drive
Chicago, IL 60606
         
One Westminster Place
Suite 200
Lake Forest, IL 60045
 
900 Third Avenue
New York, NY 10022
 
One Market, Spear Tower
32nd Floor
San Francisco, CA 94105
 
1666 K Street, NW
Suite 300
Washington, DC 20006
 

© 2007 Schiff Hardin LLP

This publication is for the general information of clients and friends of our firm. It does not provide legal advice for any specific matter. Readers should consult a lawyer directly for such advice. This publication, or parts of it, may be considered advertising material under professional conduct rules applicable to lawyers.

Click here to unsubscribe from this list.